When it comes to weight loss, cardio machines like elliptical cross trainers and treadmills are among the most popular choices. Both offer effective workouts, but they differ in impact, muscle engagement, and calorie-burning potential. If you’re trying to decide which machine is better for weight loss, this in-depth comparison will help you make an informed choice based on your fitness goals, joint health, and workout preferences.
Calorie Burn: Elliptical vs Treadmill
One of the biggest factors in weight loss is calorie expenditure. Generally, treadmills burn slightly more calories than ellipticals when running at a high intensity. According to Harvard Health, a 155-pound person can burn:
- Treadmill (running at 6 mph): 372 calories in 30 minutes
- Elliptical (vigorous effort): 335 calories in 30 minutes
However, ellipticals provide low-impact resistance training, engaging both upper and lower body muscles, which can lead to longer, more sustainable workouts for some users. If you prefer high-intensity interval training (HIIT), both machines can be adjusted for maximum fat burn.
Impact on Joints: Which is Safer?
If you have joint pain, arthritis, or are recovering from an injury, the elliptical is the better choice. It mimics a running motion without the harsh impact on knees, hips, and ankles. Treadmills, especially when running, put 3x your body weight on joints with each step, increasing injury risk over time.
That said, walking on a treadmill (especially on an incline) is still a low-impact option compared to running. If joint health is a concern but you prefer treadmills, consider power walking at a 5-10% incline for reduced strain.
Muscle Engagement: Full-Body vs Lower-Body Focus
- Elliptical: Works arms, shoulders, chest, glutes, hamstrings, and calves due to its push-pull motion. Some models offer adjustable resistance and incline, making it a full-body workout.
- Treadmill: Primarily targets legs, glutes, and core, especially when running or walking uphill. Upper body engagement is minimal unless you actively pump your arms.
If you want toned arms along with weight loss, an elliptical may be more effective. For leg strength and endurance, treadmills (especially with incline) are superior.
Workout Variety & Customization
Both machines offer programmable workouts, but treadmills generally have more built-in options:
- Treadmill: Incline adjustments, speed intervals, hill simulations, and pre-set fat-burning programs.
- Elliptical: Resistance levels, reverse motion, and upper-body handles for varied intensity.
If you get bored easily, a treadmill may provide more workout variations. However, ellipticals with pre-set programs can also keep workouts engaging.
Which is Better for Weight Loss?
The answer depends on your fitness level, joint health, and preferences:
- Choose a Treadmill If:
- You enjoy running or brisk walking.
- You want higher calorie burn in less time.
- You prefer customizable incline/speed workouts.
- You have no major joint issues.
- Choose an Elliptical If:
- You need a low-impact workout.
- You want full-body muscle engagement.
- You have back/knee problems.
- You prefer longer, steady-state cardio sessions.
You can visit the given URL to know more about elliptical Cross Trainers and treadmill.
Best Elliptical Cross Trainers for Small Space
Home Treadmill
Also click here to know more about Selecting Trolley Bag For Travel
Final Verdict
Both ellipticals and treadmills are excellent for weight loss, but the best choice depends on your needs:
- Treadmills burn calories faster but are harder on joints.
- Ellipticals provide full-body workouts with less injury risk.
For maximum fat loss, alternate between both machines to prevent plateaus and keep workouts challenging. If possible, try both at a gym before purchasing to see which feels better for your body and fitness goals.
Would you prefer an elliptical or treadmill for weight loss? Let us know in the comments!